Old Jeeps versus Newer Used Jeeps
When old Jeeps are found for sale I know my ears perk up because these great pieces of history have the same profound effect on Jeep Lovers as a 1934 Ford 3-window coupe has on a car buff.
Unless you have owned an old unrestored Jeep or can relate to owning any old fixer-upper, you know that there is a lot more to consider than just the nostalgia and your future dreams of cruising the streets, roads or trails.
Old or New?...Your opinions
are highly valued here!
I got to thinking about all of this when a visitor to this website (from India) contacted me with this question:
(paraphrased) "Hey Larry, Hope this mail finds you and your jeep in the best of health :)... I have a query and would be great if I could get your feedback.
My name is (name withheld) and am from India. Am 32 years old. As many children are, I too as a child was fascinated with Jeeps and driving them in forests. Well the forest part may not be possible for me, but yes...the dream of having a Jeep seems to be coming near...and therefore the question.
I am getting an old 1959 Willys Jeep from a re-seller, and he states that it has a Perkins DI (diesel injected) engine with 3 gears. I have seen it and it does not have any modifications and is still like the old Jeeps. I would be buying it for $3000 (USD). I do love Jeeps, but this being my first vehicle, is it wise to invest in a Jeep? What are the issues that you see I would have in the future? Once I have purchased the Jeep...what do I need to check before I finalize the purchase?
Any other suggestions or recommendations you have would be highly appreciated. Thanks and regards!"
Here is how I responded to my friend in India:
"Thanks for the question.... Although I can't speak for anyone else I can only speak for what I would do (or have done in the past). You didn't say how much mechanical ability and/or resources you have necessary to rebuild or simply keep the Jeep going. I also don't know the standard of living in your country...but $3000 is a relatively small amount here in America (depending on the overall condition of the Jeep).
That being said I am of the opinion that one needs to start somewhere, and if the price is right there would at least be a potential learning experience. How much time, effort and expense you put into your project can vary greatly, again depending on your personal abilities. Also, if your Jeep will be your primary means of transportation, or more of a hobby, that will need to be considered as well.
In my experience the older a vehicle is, the more upkeep that is necessary and parts/accessories are often harder to find. The Perkins Diesel engine may require some pretty hard to find parts as well since it was not produced for any significant length of time for Willys/Jeep.
My 1953 M38A1 Willys/Jeep was in good condition when I bought it because it had been updated somewhat...however, one problem I didn't consider at first was the fact that it was geared so low that I could hardly drive on the street (would over-rev at any speed over 40 mph). That eventually led to me sell it (although I regret it now).
So, I don't know if I answered your question well or not...but I hope this helps some. If you do decide to buy this Jeep (or another one) please consider sending a photo and a story about it here for the website: Your Jeep Page...or just scroll down a little here where it says "Which is Better..." and follow the easy instructions. I would love to see it. Take care and good luck...Larry"
Well, my visitor wrote back that he was indeed buying that old Jeep and seemed genuinely excited. (I would be too!)
Lee From Utah Loves His Old '59 CJ5...Click Photo to Read More!
Wendy's Wrangler JK Unlimited..Click Photo for More!
The time, effort and money required to rebuild, fix or just maintain old Jeeps can quickly take the fun out of owning one...but if you are as Jeep Crazy as I am...these old relics still get the adrenalin pumping with thoughts of rebuilding to specs, or creating a great trail rig.
Newer Jeeps have more modern technology, durability and comfort than the old Jeeps had, and frankly may be the better choice for most of us.
So it seems the answer to "old Jeeps versus newer Jeeps" all depends on one's individual desire, financial status, technical skills, comfort level, and needs...which when you break it all down can apply to either one...or both.
What do you think?.......
Which is better: Old Jeeps or Newer Jeeps?
The transition from the Jeep CJ's to the Wranglers is a pretty good cut-off point for older vs. newer Jeeps. So the questions are:
- Do you prefer Jeeps (any Jeep) from 1941 thru 1986, or
- Do you prefer newer Jeeps from 1987 through 2010?
- Explain your choice(s). Tell us why you prefer a particular model/year and be as specific as possible.
- Include a photo(s) (up to 4) if you own your preferred Jeep.
See What Other Have Written!
Click below to see contributions from other visitors to this page...
Can't Beat the Old Jeeps
I've wheeled and driven both and can safely say I am always going to be partial to anything 1986 and older.
Newer Wranglers are just too refined and …
The JK is a Joke! ...Go CJ's
I am a Jeep lover. I own a 1972 CJ-5 and a 1946 CJ-2a. My brother owns a '72 Commando, and my best friend owns 2 YJ's, 1 TJ and a M38a1.
The Jeep …
I prefer older Jeeps
Newer is not always better! The more things you have on a vehicle, the more you will have to eventually fix and replace.
I think that consumers …
Jeeps are Tons of Fun
I have owned almost every Jeep model.
My favorite to date was an M38A1 with the snorkel setup. It could go thru anything including water up to …
My Rebuild 1947 Jeep CJ 2A
I purchased my '47 CJ2A for $1800.00.
I had it about a year. I put new tires, basic engine parts, spark plugs, wires, fuel filter and a few …
I choose the newer Jeep Wranglers
I prefer the newer Jeeps from 1987 through 2008.
Wrangler YJ, TJ is my sole choice, especially the TJ models that were sold from 1997 to 2006. …
Prefer the newer Jeeps especially the last TJ's
I prefer newer Jeeps, in particular TJ's, the Jeep Liberty and later model YJ's.
Specifically I prefer 2006 Jeep TJ's because this was the last …
Mostly Prefer Newer Jeeps
I have a preference for the ('87-'08) Jeeps .
I especially prefer the ('97-'06) TJ. I like the stance, (narrower compared to the new JK) and …
Prefer when Jeeps were simple!
I must say that the 1986 and earlier Jeep models are hard to beat. That was back when car ECU's were not such a big deal and we did not have the exhaust …
Newer Jeeps Best with Old Jeep Memories
When I was in high school I helped my father restore a 1950 Willys. It was a huge bonding experience for us so I do prefer that year and model. …
Prefer Older Jeeps
I prefer Jeeps from 1941 to 1986 better than the jeeps from 1986 to 2008.
Jeeps from 1941 were made specially for Army and Military usage. …
Older Jeep's better than a Lamborghini
I prefer the older Jeeps, my favorite model being the Willys (which are actually the early CJ’s).
I find these to be classic vehicles that are …
Click here to write your own.
Where can I Look for a good Cheap Jeep?
Doing a site search is the easiest way to find specific info on my site
Don't know an old model Jeep from a New one? Take a look at this chronological Jeep History!
Jeep Questions and Answers. See what others have asked, or add your own!
How to Find the Best Used Jeep...Click Now!
(Return to Top of This Page..Old Jeeps)
Home|About|Site Map|Contact Me|What's New?|Disclaimer