Jeep or Hummer: Apples To Apples?

Hmmm!...let's see...Jeep or Hummer?

Which is the best off-the-showroom-floor performer in the 4x4 arena?

Okay...maybe I can't be totally unbiased in this comparison of two highly popular and unique vehicles...but I think I can be fair in that I have already been quite forthcoming regarding the perceived limitations and weaknesses of Jeeps as experienced and/or gleaned from Jeep owners, Jeep critics and various respected "motorheads".

And yes I am aware that Jeeps come in several styles and platforms so I will only focus on the Jeep Wrangler and Wrangler Unlimited model up against the Hummer H2 and H3 models.

The Hummer H1 and military HumVee are not currently available to the public and would certainly give Jeep a run for the money here, if included.

In choosing Jeep or Hummer the first question that comes to mind is "what can a Jeep do that a Hummer can't...and vice versa?"

The answer to that question requires looking at some comparative specifications for each model to get a better picture.

Here are the factory listed size and weight specs of the new H2 and H3 Hummers, as well as the new Jeep Wrangler and Jeep Wrangler Unlimited models.

Okay...now you have at least some basis for comparison between the Jeep or Hummer!

Now what was I saying...oh yeah!...what can a Jeep do that a Hummer can't...etc...etc...?

Well, in stock form the Hummer H2 is a monster in the weight department outweighing it's little cousin (H3) by almost 2000 lbs... and eclipsing the heavier of the Jeep Wranglers (Unlimited) by just under 2200 lbs.

Well, any self-respecting off road guy or gal knows that too much weight in the dirt, mud, sand and rocks can be disasterous leading to getting stuck, decreasing stability, reducing agility and putting undue stress on mechanical components.

Okay, all you H2 Hummer people out there...don't get excited. I'm not saying that the H2 isn't trail worthy or capable of handling a lot of abuse. Just remember that this is in comparison with the Jeep Wrangler's and even the H3.

Speaking of the H3 Hummer...it is at the very least comparable to the Jeep Wrangler Unlimited in the specs department. ( Jeep or Hummer ?...see more on the Unlimited...click here! ) The H3 outweighs the Unlimited by a little less than 300 lbs. and has similar dimensions in overal wheelbase, length and track...again with the H3 being slightly larger.

A number of off road (Jeep or Hummer) comparisons have been presented stating the superiority of each model in similar conditions, however there are two distinct differences which set the Jeeps apart from the Hummers...

The two absolutely critical differences between the Jeep Wranglers and both Hummers is...1) the Hummers are merely luxury Chevy Trucks...and...2) they have Independent Front Suspensions (IFS) with full-time 4 wheel drive.

The Jeep Wranglers on the other hand have solid front axles with part-time 4 wheel drive, a heritage of proven ruggedness...and...well they have the JEEP nameplate.

And...you may have noticed that I never really even got to the standard (short wheelbase) Jeep Wrangler in this comparison.

That's because in my opinion, for off road capability the original inspired "Universal" designed Jeep Wrangler is in a class all by itself.

Which Do You Think Is the Best?

Here's your chance to tell the world whether you think the Jeep Wrangler, Cherokee, Unlimited or Grand is better than the Hummer H1, H2, or H3.

Don't hold back...even if you lean heavy toward the Hummer side.

Let's hear from you Hummer guys and see if you Jeep guys can hold your own with reasons why one vehicle is better than the other.

Write your page here and have some fun with it!

Jeep or Hummer...Who Cares? Pick your truck...go off-road...HAVE FUN! That's what it's all about...

Larry's Comment: Half the fun is bragging that your truck is the best.

Don'...

Hummer Hands Down! Jeeps No Contest! Here's the deal. What Jeep owners don't want to hear is that right out of the show room floor the Hummer is better in every way.

For instance the Hummer ...

In the 4wd beginning there was... JEEP...Bantam, Willys & Ford. Then came Kaiser Willys, then AMC & Chrysler.

Jeep wrote the book on 4wd and Humdrum copied a page out of it for the ...

Hummer The Hummer is a much more capable rig no matter what any one has to say.

The thing is there are not too many people who know how it was made for the ...

My little Jeep vs Hummer... I find these comparisons somewhat silly.

Jeeps and Hummers are somewhat one in the same. They were both military vehicles at one time, and they have ...

Landy is top off roader Well sorry if I ruffle a few feathers but Land Rovers have proven time and again they will leave the Hummers and the Jeeps for dead in hard going.

Larry'...

Real men drive Jeeps Comparing Jeeps to Hummers is like comparing apples to oranges. Better yet, like comparing real men to sissy men. Even better, like comparing people who ...

My own Hummer Jeep For those who want the best of both worlds there is an after market fiberglass body for Wranglers that makes it look like a Hummer.

I believe it was ...

I have owned both JK and H3. Some good and bad to each. Jeep guy all my life until recently. Had the JK Rubicon as a work/fun vehicle and due to endless water leaks in the Freedom Top had to have something ...

Jeeps vs. Hummers If you talk practical, Jeeps are the only way to go. One of the first 4wd's in America. It's simply the best!

The only Hummer I would buy would be ...

JEEP ALL THE WAY! Well I got very few words to say, but that Hummer is just a waste of money. One that buys a Hummer is doing it to say hey I'm a rich ***. I'm going to ...

faverate Jeep wins!

Jeep is more practical For an off road vehicle I would prefer an older Jeep than a Hummer. Although there is a certain stigma that comes along with owning and driving a Hummer,...

Go With Hummer! My pick would definitely be the Hummer. The Land Rover is nice, and if I wanted a capable luxurious 4-Wheeler, I would choose that, but who cares about ...

Hummers Not Worth It Jeeps are better. They are less top heavy and lighter in general. You can also get an upgrade for the Rock-Trac transfer case with the low-range ratio ...

Why I choose Jeep Unless it was the original Hummer, I would have to choose a Jeep. They are more convenient and don’t guzzle down the gas as bad, although, neither of them ...

I Prefer Hummer I prefer the Hummer for the off-road because a Hummer can cope better with the off-road terrain and still let you ride in comfort. A Hummer can get through ...

like-my-rubicon-best For an off road vehicle, I personally prefer the Jeep. The Hummer is a great vehicle, but regardless whether the Hummer performs, many people look at ...

jeep-over-hummers If I was to pick between a Jeep and a Hummer I would have to easily pick the Jeep for an off-road vehicle. The hummer has an image that jeep will never ...

the-jeep-commander-is-better I believe that one of the best off road vehicles is the Jeep Commander. I own one myself, and I wouldn’t own any other vehicle. I have taken it off road ...

hummer-cool-factor The Jeep has certainly been around a long time and has starred in a number of tv shows and movies such as MASH, The Gods Must Be Crazy, and any World ...

i-prefer-jeeps I prefer a Jeep to a Hummer, for aesthetic and personal reasons. I think Hummers are ridiculously large and eat up too much gas. I think especially in ...

Bad Hummers and Jeeps I liked the Hummer when it first came out. You know the military used them and they really looked cool, but most of all they seemed to be great offroad....

Jeep or Hummer: Apples to Apples?

Which Do You Think Is the Best?

What Others Have Submitted